Songs to make him think of me?

I will soon be going somewhere with a guy that I like and a mutual friend. Probably camping or a small trip so there will be a lot of music involved. We plan on making cds and sharing music with each other. I have a crush on him and I think he likes me too. I want to make a cd of songs that will kind of...have him looking at me, know what I mean? Like that moment in movies when the guy looks at the girl and just knows. I really like indie music. So does he. I want the songs to capture that butterfly-in-the-stomach feeling. But nothing like Taylor Swift. I like soft, raspy voices. I want to ride shotgun while the sun is setting and I want him to peek over at me and just fall in love. Any suggestions?